Menus About Us Catering Store Ithaca Bakery Locations Order Lunch Purchase Gifts Gift Cards
  • Order Lunch
  • Purchase Gifts
  • Gift Cards
How Do I?
  • - Apply for a job?
  • - Place a lunch order?
  • - Make my catered event successful?
  • - Find the soup of the day?
  • - Place a wholesale order?
  • - Check my gift card balance?
SandwichesText ShadowText Shadow

Sandwiches

HomeMenusSandwiches
Farm to Bakery Empire State Favorites Specialty Sandwiches NY Deli Style Grilled Panini Hoagie Sandwiches Breakfast Sandwiches Bagel Sandwiches

Our sandwiches are each handcrafted and second to none in creativity, quality and taste. An incredible selection from cold to hot, vegan to free range beef and everything in between will certainly give everyone something to enjoy.

Please call 273-2890 ext. 2 for daily sandwich and soup specials.

DOWNLOAD OUR FULL SANDWICH MENU HERE

Farm to Bakery


  • Dag's New Rochelle
    10.95

    Quad-decker with house-cured ham, turkey, capicolla, salami, Swiss, Provolone, lettuce, tomato, mustard & mayo, on our toasted Sourdough. REALLY big! *No substitutions on this sandwich please.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Jamie's Jambon
    9.95

    House-cured ham, with Manchego cheese, mango-ancho chili chutney & basil oil, on our Ciabatta bread.

  • Eddie's Free Bird
    8.95

    Grilled free-range chicken breast with Dinosaur BBQ Sauce, warmed with melted Cuba Cheddar, lettuce and tomato, on our toasted honey onion roll.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Marley
    9.50

    Local High Point grass-fed roast beef, mango-ancho chili chutney, carmalized onions & jerk sauce, on our toasted Ciabatta bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Chicken Curry
    8.95

    Free-range chicken with curry sauce, caramelized onions, peppers & grilled pineapple, pressed on our French bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Rick's Casablanca
    8.95

    Local house-cured smoked ham, caramelized onions, tomato & garlic spread, with melted Manchego cheese melted, on our buttered toasted French bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Laura's Sweet Surprise
    8.95

    Local pulled pork - locally raised, Manchego cheese, caramelized onions, Heller's local strawberry jam & balsamic reduction, served warm on our toasted French bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Upstate Banh Mi
    8.50

    Traditional Southeast Asian sandwich made with local roast pork, jicama slaw, cucumber, mayonnaise, soy sauce, chilii oil & cilantro, on our French roll.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery

Empire State Favorites


  • Miles To Go
    9.95

    House-cured ham, Pepper Jack cheese, tomato-garlic spreas & spinach, grilled on our hand-sliced Multi-grain bread.

    • Ithaca9.95
  • Beef on Weck
    9.50

    Local High Point grass-fed beef - top round - with horseradish, served au jus, on our toasted Kimmelwick roll.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Buffalo9.50
  • Augie's New Spiedie
    8.95

    Free-range chicken breast, marinated in local State Fair Spiedie Sauce and grilled with peppers, onions arugula & melted Provolone, on our mini-French roll.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Endicott8.95
  • West Willow BBQ
    8.50

    Local roast pork in Dinosaur BBQ sauce, topped with house-made coleslaw, on our fresh-baked Honey roll.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Syracuse8.50
  • Ramona's Big Adventure
    9.95

    Local High Point grass-fed beef, fresh Mozzarella, Heller's local arugula, tomato, fresh basil oil, on our pumpernickel bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • T-Burg9.95
  • Jib's Jaybird
    7.25

    Local seitan with melted Swiss cheese, banana peppers, local horseradish & Dinosaur BBQ Sauce, on our toasted Ciabatta bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
    • Ithaca7.25

Specialty Sandwiches


  • Turkey & Smoked Turkey

    • Danby Revisited
      7.75

      Smoked turkey breast, avocado, tomato & house-made parsley-garlic dressing, on our hand-sliced Multi-grain bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Flat Rock
      8.25

      Roast turkey, fresh local goat cheese, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh basil, extra-virgin olive oil & balsamic vinegar, on our Baguette.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Sweet Rachel
      6.95

      Smoked turkey, Muenster cheese, honey mustard & sweet red onion, on hand-sliced Pumpernickel bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Lindsey
      6.95

      Turkey, mushrooms, parsley-garlic dressing & melted Muenster, on our Bialy.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • California Dreamin'
      7.95

      Smoked turkey breast, avocado & creamy coleslaw, on our hand-sliced Multi-grain bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Turkey Hill BLT
      8.25

      Turkey, bacon, aioli dressing, lettuce & tomato, on hand-sliced Pumpernickel bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • The Octopus
      7.25

      Roast turkey breast, house-made coleslaw, Russian dressing & Swiss cheese, on our Pumpernickel bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Chicken & Fish

    • Olympian
      8.25

      House-roasted chicken breast, Feta cheese, fresh spinach, tomato & vinaigrette dressing, in a sun-dried tomato Wrap.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Amy's Off Fishin'
      8.95

      Lox, egg salad, cucumber, lettuce, tomato & sprouts, on our toasted Wheat bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Fulton St. Melt
      6.50

      House-made albacore tuna OR chicken salad with tomato & melted Cheddar, open-face on our plain Bagel

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • K's Roasted & Blue
      7.95

      Roast chicken, bacon, Stilton, stone ground mustard & honey spread, red onion & arugula, on our toasted hand-sliced Pumpernickel bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Brighton Beach
      7.95

      Whitefish salad with chive cream cheese, capers, lettuce & tomato, on our toasted Rye bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • T-Burg with a Twist
      6.95

      House-made albacore tuna salad with avocado & tomato, on our Pumpernickel bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Tuscan Verde
      8.50

      House-roasted chicken breast with house-made pesto, fresh spinach, fresh tomato & Provolone cheese, on our Rosemary Focaccia bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Chicken Or The Egg?
      7.95

      Chicken cutlet with hard-boiled egg, melted Provolone cheese, with arugula & chipotle aioli, on our toasted Honey-Onion roll.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Mt. Pleasant
      6.75

      House-roasted chicken breast, fresh spinach, tomato & chipotle aioli, on our Sourdough bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Ham, Bacon & Salami

    • Euro
      7.50

      Ham, Brie cheese, red onion & Dijon mustard, on Ciabatta bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Earl's Ham & Honey
      6.95

      Ham, Swiss, cucumber, arugula & stone-ground mustard, on our Honey-Onion roll.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • The Zep
      7.95

      Extra salami, tomato, red onion, Provolone, banana peppers & herb vinaigrette, on our own Baguette.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • C.T.B.L.T.
      5.95

      Bacon, lettuce & tomato, with aioli dressing & avocado, on our toasted Sourdough bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Beef

    • Favorite Uncle Harry
      8.50

      Pastrami with melted Cuba Cheddar, & jicama slaw, on our toasted French bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Court Street Beef
      7.25

      Rare roast beef with parsley-garlic cream cheese, lettuce & tomato, on our Rye bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Duke of Lansing
      7.95

      Rare roast beef, Stilton cheese, lettuce, tomato and whole-grain mustard on hand-sliced pumpernickel bread.

  • Vegetarian & Vegan

    • Viva Chelsea!
      6.50

      Fresh Mozzarella cheese with fresh basil, tomato, extra-virgin olive oil, salt & pepper, on our Rosemary Focaccia bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Jonah's Jive
      5.50

      House-made hummus, fresh spinach, tomato, cucumber & parsley-garlic dressing, on our hand-sliced Multi-grain bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Susie's Garden
      7.95

      Seitan, vegan Mozzarella, avocado, lettuce, tomato & sprouts, on our own Oatmeal Wheat bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegan
    • Dewitt Melt
      4.25

      House-made coleslaw, tomato & melted Swiss cheese, on our fresh Bialy.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Cayuga Croissant
      5.25

      Avocado, tomato, mushrooms, sprouts & parsley-garlic dressing, on a Croissant.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Buttermilk Bialy
      4.25

      Melted Muenster, tomato, sprouts & Dijon, on our fresh Bialy.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Michigan Hollow
      6.95

      Warm balsamic-marinated portobello mushroom with roasted red peppers, parsley-garlic dressing & melted Provolone cheese, on our Multi-grain roll.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • East Falls
      6.95

      Veggie burger, mushrooms, caramelized onions, Dinosaur BBQ Sauce, tomato & melted Swiss, on our Multi-grain roll.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Van Dorn's Vegan
      4.95

      House-made hummus, roasted red peppers, tomato & sprouts, on Oatmeal Wheat bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegan
    • Cascadilla Crisp
      5.15

      Sliced cucumber, roasted red peppers, fresh tomato, red onion, sprouts & parsley-garlic dressing, on our hand-sliced Multi-grain bread.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian

NY Deli Style

Served on Oatmeal Wheat, Pumpernickel, Rye, or Sourdough breads, Wraps, Baguette, Bialy, Ciabatta, Kaiser roll, Multi-Grain roll or Focaccia.

Croissant, Hand-sliced Pumpernickel or Multi-Grain bread, add 50¢.

With choice of Mayo; Dijon, Deli or honey mustard; Russian, Aioli, Chipotle Aioli, Parsley-Garlic, or Vinaigrette dressing; lettuce, tomato, sprouts, banana peppers or red onion.

Add two slices of cheese: American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Muenster, Provolone, Pepper Jack, Swiss or Vegan Mozzarella, add 75¢.

Half of a NY Deli Sandwich is half-price plus 75¢.


  • Cheese
    5.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Chicken Salad
    5.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Corned Beef
    6.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Egg Salad
    3.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Genoa Salami
    5.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Free-Range Chicken
    8.50
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Grass-Fed Beef (High Point Farms)
    9.50
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Hummus
    3.95
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegan
  • Ham
    5.50
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Pastrami
    6.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Prosciutto
    6.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Roast Beef
    6.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Roast Chicken Breast
    6.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Seitan (Susie's)
    6.50
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegan
  • Roast Pork (Pork Chop Valley)
    7.95
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Smoked Turkey
    6.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • House-Cured Ham
    8.95
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Tuna Salad (Solid White)
    5.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Turkey
    5.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Vegan Chicken Salad
    6.50
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegan
  • Vegan Mozzarella
    5.95
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegan

Grilled Panini


  • Renwick Reuben
    7.75

    Corned beef, sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese and homemade Russian dressing on toasted rye bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Cuban
    8.95

    Local pork & dijon mustard, Oink & Gobble smoked ham, dill pickles and melted Swiss cheese on toasted, buttered French bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Milanese
    8.25

    House-roasted chicken breast, roasted red peppers, pesto mayonnaise, melted Provolone cheese & Italian herbs on rosemary focaccia bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Parisian
    7.75

    Roast turkey breast, three-fruit chutney, fresh spinach and melted Brie on toasted sourdough bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Italian
    8.25

    Genoa salami, thinly sliced Prosciutto, pesto, spinach, tomato and melted Provolone cheese on toasted rosemary focaccia bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Tina's Best
    8.95

    Local grass-fed roast beef with Cuba Cheddar, banana peppers, caramelized onions, 3-fruit chutney & spinach, on our French bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Sherwood Forest
    7.75

    Balsamic-marinated Portobello mushroom, tomato, pesto, Mozzarella cheese on our Ciabatta bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Campania
    7.95

    Fresh Mozzarella cheese with sun-dried tomatoes and fresh arugula on toasted sourdough bread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • The Fusion
    7.25

    Lemon teriyaki seitan with caramelized onions, fresh spinach and banana peppers on toasted oatmeal wheat bread

    • Available for Lunch Delivery

Hoagie Sandwiches

Available at the Ithaca Bakery stores, Meadow St. & Triphammer only.
All hoagies are made on our own Italian hoagie rolls.


  • Planet Milo
    8.95

    Roast chicken, proscuitto, tomato-garlic spread, melted Provolone, arugula & red onion.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The King’s Italian Hoagie
    6.99

    Prosciutto, salami, capicola, Provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, basil oil.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Ithaca Bakery Special
    6.99

    Roast beef, turkey, ham, chive cream cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, basil oil.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Mr. Haskell
    7.45

    Corned beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, onion, Russian dressing, basil oil.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The Cutlet
    7.95

    Chicken cutlet with Italian herbs, Provolone, basil mayo, roasted peppers.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • The South Hill Slide
    6.99

    Roast turkey breast, Provolone, basil mayo, roasted peppers, basil oil.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Potter’s Pick
    6.99

    Fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper, spinach, basil oil, salt & pepper.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • The Zorba
    7.50

    Spinach, cucumber, artichoke, tomato, red onion, Feta & Kalamata olive spread, topped with oregano and lemon vinaigrette, on our Tortano roll.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian

Breakfast Sandwiches


  • Breakfast Sandwiches

    • Steak & Eggs
      5.95

      Roast beef, scrambled eggs, roasted red peppers & melted Pepper Jack, on our Plain bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Big Sur
      4.95

      Sausage, scrambled eggs, tomato & melted Pepper Jack, on our plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Bronx Bagel
      3.95

      Scrambled eggs with sausage, on our plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • with cheese4.70
    • Brooklyn Bagel
      3.95

      Scrambled eggs with bacon, on our plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • with cheese4.70
    • Eggs Christina
      3.95

      Scrambled eggs with ham, on our plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • with cheese4.70
    • Eggs Melissa
      3.95

      Scrambled eggs with melted Cheddar cheese on our a plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • The Florentine
      5.70

      Scrambled eggs, mushrooms, Feta & fresh spinach, on a spinach Wrap.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Soho Croissant
      5.75

      Veggie cream cheese, mushrooms, tomato & melted Swiss cheese on a croissant.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Huevos Sonora
      5.50

      Scrambled eggs, avocado, fresh salsa & Cheddar cheese, in a honey-wheat Wrap.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Tex Mex
      4.50

      Scrambled eggs with house-made salsa & melted Cheddar, on our plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • The Sunrise
      4.75

      Scrambled eggs with avocado, red onion & melted Pepper Jack cheese, on our plain Bagel.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Medusa
      5.95

      Tofu scramble with spinach, house-made pesto & tomato, on a sun-dried tomato Wrap

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegetarian
    • Tofu 4 U
      4.95

      Scrambled tofu with onions and spices, fresh salsa & vegan Mozzarella, in a tomato Wrap.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegan
    • Veganic Wrap
      5.95

      Tofu scramble with avocado, mushrooms & red onions, on a sun-dried tomato Wrap.

      • Available for Lunch Delivery
      • Vegan

Bagel Sandwiches


  • Butter
    1.45
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Cream Cheese or Philly Light
    2.45
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Tofutti
    3.70
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Whitefish Salad
    5.95
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Nova Lox & Cream Cheese
    8.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Whipped Cream Cheese
    2.95

    Choose from: Chive, Parsley-Garlic, Scallion, Jalapeno, Green Olive, Cinnamon-Raisin, Honey-Walnut, Strawberry.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Veggie, Veggie-Light, Bacon-Scallion
    3.19
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Peanut Butter, Jam & Preserves
    2.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Cinnamon-Sugar & Butter
    2.05
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Peanut Butter & Jelly
    2.50
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Melted Cheese
    2.75

    American, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Muenster, Provolone, Pepper Jack, Swiss, Vegan Mozzarella

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Pizza Bagel
    3.60

    Pizza sauce & melted Mozzarella

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Add Peperoni4.35
  • Honey & Butter
    2.25
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Nova
    3.75
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
  • Mexican Bagel
    4.60

    Jalapeno cream cheese, fresh salsa & melted Cheddar

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Extras on sandwiches under 3.75
    .50

    Lettuce, tomato, sprouts, banana peppers or onions.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegan
  • Nutella
    3.19
    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • San Diego Bagel
    3.25

    Bagel with cream cheese & raspberry-jalapeno spread.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian
  • Vegetarian Bagel
    4.60

    Veggie cream cheese, tomato & melted Muenster cheese.

    • Available for Lunch Delivery
    • Vegetarian

Farm to Bakery Empire State Favorites Specialty Sandwiches NY Deli Style Grilled Panini Hoagie Sandwiches Breakfast Sandwiches Bagel Sandwiches

Menus

  • Home
  • Menus
  • About Us
  • Catering
  • Store
  • Company
  •  
  • Mailing List
  • Facebook
  • Yelp
  • Twitter
  • Home
    • How Do I...
      • Apply for a job?
      • Place a lunch order?
      • Make my catered event successful?
      • Find the soup of the day?
      • Place a wholesale order?
      • Check my gift card balance?
    • Free Lunch Delivery Mon-Fri, 11-2pm
    • Bagels
    • Breads
    • Cayuga Coffee
    • Wedding Cakes
    • Wedding Cake Inquiry
  • Menus
    • Today's Soups
    • Monthly Specials Flyer
    • Sandwiches
    • Platters
    • Drinks
    • Grab & Go!
    • Catering
    • Chips & Snacks
    • Holiday Specials
    • Entrees & Salads
    • Desserts
    • Meals To Go
  • About Us
    • Locations & Hours
    • History
    • Sustainable
    • Club Cards
    • Newsletter
    • News & Events
  • Catering
    • Breakfast
    • Hors d'Oeuvres
    • Platters
    • Barbecues
    • Dinners
    • Desserts
    • Rentals & Service
    • Contact Catering
  • Store
    • Gift Cards
    • Shopping Cart
    • Policy
  • Company
    • Careers
    • Local Links
    • Online Job Application
    • Send Feedback
    • Contact Information
    • Contact Ithaca Bakery
  • 400 N. Meadow Street
    607-273-7110
  • Triphammer Mall
    607-257-2255
Collegetown Bagels
©2012 Ithaca Bakery. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by Webtree • Site by AWP